How many times have you complained that your partner, friend, family member, coworker, boss…someone, anyone, everyone….didn’t say what they mean and mean what they say? How many times that you preferred to hear what’s in the () aka their thought bubble rather than what they actually said? Do you often ask for and expect others to provide this common courtesy..this simple request …only to feel short changed when you don’t receive it? Do you then wonder why you weren’t important enough, valued enough, or loved enough to deserve this simple act of honesty and then slide down the familiar rabbit hole wherein no one (aside from you) is upfront, real, true to self, etc….only to decide that you are better off without them or anyone else whose word is not their bond?
If this describes you to the T, I have good news for you…you’re not alone. In some way shape or form we all fit this bill at some point in time either as the person feeling short changed or the person doing the short changing. The important question though is, how did we get there? Think about the last time you encountered this situation from either side. Ask yourself what kept you and/or the other person/people from speaking your/their truth.
In doing so, you may find that there are many reasons and some of them are unbeknownst to you or them. On the surface we can chalk it up to someone not being genuine and/or truly caring about us which made us scared to open up and share our feelings and then be hurt. Easy to make someone else the villain and give ourselves a pass by using our perception of their behavior as justification for why we weren’t our best selves in the first place.
Below are two versions of an actual conversation between Ben and Erica, who have had a tumultuous relationship paved with friendship, love, hurt, deception and uncertainty.
As you read the conversation you may align with one or the other and/or both of them. If you happen to pick sides, ask yourself why and be honest. Then read my analysis as an opportunity to explore your understanding of both positions, and possibly yourself.
Ben: I didn’t expect a text from you today.
Erica: Why? It’s your birthday.
Ben: Exactly. I expected you to call not text. It threw me off for a minute but I guess I should be glad you thought of me.
Erica: Oh sorry.
(silence then polite conversation)
Ben: Look, I know I’ve been distant lately..not because I’m distancing myself but because I’ve been so caught up with work and the kids. In a few months things will calm down and the kids will be back with their mom and I promise you I will be more available.
Erica: Okay.
Ben: But I haven’t heard from you either. It’s like you are distancing yourself from me in order to protect yourself.
Erica: No. I’m just giving you space.
Ben: Semantics. Isn’t that the same as you being distant?
Erica: No. It’s me giving you space.
What are Ben and Erica really talking about?
It appears that Ben is addressing their lack of communication and Erica not calling him on his birthday. Erica’s response is indifferent, like it’s not a big deal. She attributes her lack of communication to her giving him space because he is so busy. At least this is what their words are communicating, which would be fine if we only communicated by the words we used. However, we truly communicate with the intention behind the words we use. If you re-read the conversation again (as it is presented below) listening to their intention (in the parenthesis), the conversation is different. What are they really saying?
Ben: I didn’t expect a text from you today. (damn. I wasn’t even worth a call?! That really hurt)
Erica: Why? It’s your birthday. (why would I not wish you happy birthday? I mean I didn’t want to like this but….how could I not?)
Ben: Exactly. I expected you to call not text. It threw me off for a minute but I guess I should be glad you thought of me. (Are you serious? I shouldn’t even need to explain this. Birthday text vs a call? If I expected anyone to call me today, it was you. Sigh)
Erica: Oh sorry. (more like sorry not sorry. I’m not going to risk calling you for you to ignore my call because you’re with some chick and “too busy” to answer. I’m not going to keep crushing on you while you do you. What about all the years I couldn’t call OR text you because you chose to be with someone else?! That shit was hurtful but you weren’t worried about me then ‘cause you had her. You’ve always had a “her.”)
(silence then polite conversation)
Ben: Look, I know I’ve been distant lately..not because I’m distancing myself but because I’ve been so caught up with work and the kids. In a few months things will calm down and the kids will be back with their mom and I promise you I will be more available. (damn. I know this sucks but I need more time. I can’t meet your expectations now but as we move forward I just want to do right by you this time. This time we make it work. No exceptions. I just need you to work with me. Once my plate isn’t so full I can focus on us and give you more time.)
Erica: Okay. (as usual I’m not a priority and have to wait my turn)
Ben: But I haven’t heard from you either. It’s like you are distancing yourself from me in order to protect yourself. (I know you can’t trust me and that I don’t deserve you to but..… I’m owning that I messed things up. I know I hurt you and I’m sorry. I hate being the bad guy. I can’t keep being the bad guy.)
Erica: No. I’m just giving you space. (WTF do you want from me?! I can’t keep chasing you. I can’t keep begging you to pay attention. I’m tired of always being available when you are ready to take me off hold. When you want me you can put work in and come find me).
Ben: Semantics. Isn’t that the same as you being distant? (c’mon we both know you are in protection mode. I know you! Just admit it.)
Erica: No. It’s me giving you space. (Of course I’m protecting myself! I’m not a priority and you know it. I’m tired of feeling like I gotta get in where I fit in. You’ve given me NO reason to believe that it’s safe to take a risk again so I’m not taking one. I want you back in my life more than you may ever know but I can’t be vulnerable or dumb again.)
How different would this conversation have been if they shared their intention (thought bubbles) instead of just words? What would Ben know that would help him better understand Erica’s distance? What would Erica understand about Ben’s true intentions regarding their relationship?
ERICA
Sending a text versus making a phone call is a clear choice and message. The impersonal tone is not lost on Ben but Erica’s actual intention is. It appears as though Erica is not being true to an established pattern of communication and Ben thinks he knows what he did to move her off center, which empowered him to call out what he noticed. However, despite Ben owning this and believing things will change once he is more available, there didn’t seem to be any resolution. What went wrong in this conversation? What did Erica want to hear that Ben didn’t say? And vice versa?
1. Erica wrote the script but didn’t share it with Ben
Many of us have a running script in our head about how people are supposed to act, conversations are supposed to flow and how life is supposed to work out. Thinking ahead is all well and good except for the fact that we rarely share the script with our leading wo/man or our cast and crew. We walk around expecting everyone to know their lines and act out the italicized (theatrical directions) and become disappointed when they miss their “cue” leading to miscommunication and bad feelings on both ends.
Erica has unmet needs but denies interest in sharing them with the only person who can attempt to meet them. However, she expects Ben to “come find” her when he’s ready. How is Ben supposed to know that’s what she needs/wants, if he wasn’t given the script? Ben did what he thought the situation called for and communicated his observations only to get no validation. How does the apparent lack of appreciation for his ownership and explanation translate for Ben? Erica appears to be tired of hearing his words and seeing little action to back it up while Ben may feel that his communication is his only available demonstration of accepting responsibility. She has assumed that he has never missed her text or call on his birthday and has used this to rationalize and weaponize her position. However, assumptions are dangerous when taken as fact. If she doesn’t feel like a priority and acts as though she has accepted this as the status quo, how can she let him know she wants/needs to feel like one and in turn make him one?
2. Erica has asked for something she didn’t give
We all come with dings in our armor (i.e….insecurities) and our hardest trick is to keep the new car smell in a pre-owned vehicle (i.e.…appear unscathed by past hurts even though we have been severely altered by them). But if you are able to accomplish this impossible feat- does that make the car new again? It’s all perspective. Truth is subjective and magical-there one minute and gone the next. Easy to ask for and expect yet hard as hell to earn and maintain. Erica wants to know how Ben really feels about her. She wants to know his intentions but she can’t bring herself to tell him how she feels. Is it fair to expect someone to “keep it real” and tell you where they stand all while you refuse to do the same from them? She justifies it as being okay because she is protecting herself but how is that fair? Ben realizes her behavior is different so can he be expected to risk when he sees her not taking risks even if he knows why? Regardless of how we rationalize our perspective (or truth) if our actions don’t create safe space for sharing intimate thoughts, fears and concerns then it also doesn’t leave room to feasibly expect anyone to trust us with their vulnerability. We can’t play victim while being the villain.
3. Erica is so focused on being right that she is wrong
One word. PROTECTION. Erica isn’t flinching first. She refuses to be vulnerable and let Ben know how much she cares about him or their situation out of fear that doing so somehow makes her weak or susceptible to being taken advantage of. As long as she is so sure she will be screwed again she will want him to prove that he is truly ride or die. She will act tougher than nails and nonchalant about what he says and/or does only to convey the exact opposite of what she is feeling inside. However, none of this draws her closer to her goal. In fact, it takes her further away from it. Deep down Erica wants to feel safe with Ben but she can’t say that, because it makes her vulnerable and in her head it creates expectations Ben may not want. What if he doesn’t feel the same way? What if he feels like she’s rushing him or applying unwanted pressure? Erica doesn’t want this so it feels safer to maintain her poker face and keep bluffing (i.e…pretend she is okay “giving him space” vs engaging with him regularly). Makes perfect sense in Vegas but not so much when you are managing a relationship you want to materialize.
BEN
So here Ben realizes things have shifted and inquires about where Erica stands. Erica acts aloof as if there’s no problem. Why would she do that? He is owning that he recognizes she texted instead of calling as a form of protection and addresses his contribution. Why not meet him where he is and say that she feels he should be making more of an effort and that she feels slighted and is in fact questioning what they are doing and moving into protection mode?
1. Ben wrote the script but didn’t share it with Erica
Ben knows exactly what Erica is feeling and why and simplifies it to availability because that’s easier than addressing the real problem- aka he’s playing victim while being the villain. He demonizes Erica’s apparent distance while absolving himself from it because he has “a lot going on” and she is “being distant to protect” herself. However, is it possible that Ben has so much going on as a way to protect himself from being in a position to give more than he is offering? Could this be why emotional distance is an issue?
Ben expects Erica to own that she’s protecting herself and accept that he will be more available in a few months. If she does, problem solved. Right? Maybe in theory…but what if she can’t or doesn’t want to accept that? What if that doesn’t meet her needs? Does that mean she’s not being understanding and now Ben gets to be her victim? He needs time but what about what she needs? Who’s responsibility is that? Can she ask him to be more available now? Is that the same as Ben asking for more time or is this Erica being selfish? Is there a way for them both to have their needs met here?
2. Ben is expecting something he cannot give
Ben has verbally acknowledged the role he plays in their emotional distance. As a result, he is asking Erica to be open to sharing her feelings. Problem is, he is requesting she do so in an environment that is not conducive to this. Ben is able to tell her how he feels, probably because Erica has made this safe for him. As a result, Erica has been given the responsibility of being open and honest about her feelings in a situation wherein her feelings are injured because she doesn’t feel as though he has availed himself to consider them.
Typical relationship catch 22. ‘Tell me how you feel even though I haven’t created a safe environment for you to do so.’ It appears as though Ben is available to check in about his distance only because Erica injured his feelings by texting and not calling. However, her silence- though obviously noted by him- did not warrant this check in when it only represented her pain. Why does it feel safer for Ben to use texting as the opening versus addressing their distance overall? ’I care but I only tell/show you when I’m backed into a corner’ is a mixed message that inevitably keeps the relationship feeling insecure for both of them.
3. Ben is so focused on being wrong that he is losing a winning battle
When are compromise and understanding fair and when are they too much to ask? Ben is right. Erica is being distant as a form of protection and yes his busy schedule is contributing to her insecurity. What if Erica owned this? What if she said “yes I don’t feel safe so I’m backing up”? Would Ben then rejoice in being right or would he realize that he now has put himself in the position to truly acknowledge her honesty and pain and adjust his behavior today as opposed to in the few months he has allotted for himself? If he doesn’t what message is he sending? Should Erica not expect him to change and feel obligated to allot a few months for hope that his plate clears and he can be more attentive and engaged or should she remember when he told her “people make time for what they want to make time for”?
Take home message
The average person craves honest and open communication but they don’t always realize how much comes with what they seek. To share openly means all parties willingly accept a vulnerable position. Because not everything should be spoken, when we ask someone to unleash everything we have to be prepared for hearing what we may not want to hear…and then humble ourselves to realize it may have been what we needed to hear.
Some may say, ‘I’m not asking for everything, just some things.’ Understandable. Ask yourself who determines what those “somethings” are though. And what if the things you want classify as part of “everything” to the other party? As you untangle this web you may come to find that the best communication is actually the one where you don’t expect complete honesty and allow folks to share what needs to be shared in order to have both their individual needs and the relationship needs met in a selfishly unselfish way.
If Ben can hear “‘no it’s not okay that you use ‘having so much going on’ as a crutch. I’m not feeling valued and that’s not okay. I want to understand but it’s hard when I feel like I’m the only one understanding” and move towards validation and solution without getting in his feelings and being a victim he is allowing for open communication from an injured partner.
If Erica can hear “your distance feels like punishment and that confuses me. I want us to figure out how to both be okay in this transition” and move towards validation and solution without hearing his words as ‘more excuses and cop outs’ she is allowing for open communication from a trying partner.
In both examples each person is having their individual needs met (selfishly) while attending to what their relationship is asking for (unselfishly). Neither gave away the store yet both feel heard, loved and valued which allows them to see solution on the horizon.
#WINNING